See the graphic below for how to choose the appropriate weight. As of June 2020, they were also almost entirely sold out. None of the other comforters we tried felt nearly as cloudlike or light as this one. APSMILE Heavyweight European Goose Down Comforter, Elegant Comfort Heavy Weight Comforter Set, UGG Blissful Reversible Quilted Fleece Comforter, 1. It costs $60 more. After a new round of testing, we’ll be adding a couple new picks, including the Casaluna Mid Weight Down Comforter as our new budget pick. It feels a lot cheaper than the high-quality ones from Snowe and Riley we recommend immediately out of the box. Travel + Leisure is a registered trademark of Meredith Corporation Travel + Leisure Group All Rights Reserved, registered in the United States and other countries. Duck down is generally not as fluffy as goose, because most of it is from small ducks with small puffs of down. Remember to be extra gentle. But for the price ($430 for a medium-weight queen at the time of writing), we think you’d be better off going for our upgrade pick from Feathered Friends, which feels much loftier. I am in love.”. Don't let the low cost fool you: It has over 35,000 five-star reviews from users who call it both lightweight and fluffy. The Riley Goose Down Comforter is one of the lightest, fluffiest comforters we’ve tested. In any case, they’re all covered in a 100 percent cotton sateen shell, made in the USA, and dry clean only — so don’t toss this one in the washing machine! My partner is starting to call it my ‘cloud’ now too lol. Don't take my word for it: Over 2,000 Amazon reviewers rave. We eliminated many of the competitors in the budget category because they had thin-feeling or poorly made outer shells that seemed likely to wear out more quickly. (See our Care and maintenance section for more details about cleaning.) The Bean is nearly as puffy as the Riley, although the Riley’s down clusters are larger. We may receive a portion of sales from products purchased from this article, which was written by our Commerce team. The Riley is available in two weights, which the company calls all season and extra warmth. Plus, it’s box stitch construction ensures that the fill stays spread evenly throughout the comforter—no weird hot spots. The Company Store’s Organic Cotton Down Comforter’s shell felt like it was made from very low-quality cotton, and the stitching looked shoddy. It feels silky to the touch, fits our king size bed perfectly, and is warm as toast.”. The blanket itself is a decent weight, but I feel like your heat during the night makes it heavier. So thick in fact that one of our testers compared it to a memory foam mattress. APSMILE Heavyweight European Goose Down Comforter, 2. (It’s also sold out.). We didn’t even bother sleeping under it. So a higher thread count means less breathability and more heat. Buffy also offers a free 30-day trial so you can make sure you love it. Paying attention to overall weight, breathability, loft, and fabric texture, we noted which models felt the best and the worst after sleeping under each for one or two nights. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. The Downlite Hotel & Resort European Down Comforter is well-priced and well-made, but we found it to be too warm and heavy to sleep comfortably under. It’s lofty and warm but not too hot, and it feels superlight to sleep under. I was a little worried about whether it would have the same feel and warmth as the down and I was wrong. Baffle-box construction is more labor-intensive and tends to be regarded as higher quality, but we found that many of the sewn-through comforters we tested—including our luxurious upgrade pick—were just as warm and fluffy as those with baffles. To find out what makes an excellent comforter, we spoke with Jack Sukalac, an engineer who started repairing down comforters 40 years ago and since then has kept up a side business, All About Down, making and repairing down comforters in his Seattle basement. The Best Mattresses That Come in a Box for Every Sleeper (And Every Budget)The Best Bath Towels to Replace Your Old Moldy Shower RagsThe Best Sheets Will Make You Unreasonably Excited to Go to SleepThe Best Pillows for Every Type of SleeperThe Best Hand Soaps for an Instagram-Worthy Sink Ledge. Credit: The Garnet Hill Essential Down Comforter will be an also great pick for kids. The light fill and airy construction make this comforter more versatile for year-round use (or for warmer climates) than any other we’ve ever tried—many of the other heavier comforters we recommend are best for use in the coldest months. From left: Target Fieldcrest Warmest Down Comforter, Feathered Friends Bavarian Medium 700 Down Comforter, and Riley Goose Down Comforter. And with this handy list, you won’t have to look very far: We’ve chosen a selection of luxuriously cozy, fluffy finds that will keep you and your family snug no matter how low the mercury plunges — and help save you from sky-high heating bills that make your blood run cold. The Riley’s tightly woven shell fabric didn’t allow any down to leak out, but it was also softer to the touch than most other comforters we tried. The Feathered Friends comforter in the medium weight has a luxurious hand feel. Not only is this one Amazon's Choice for comforters, it's a total steal compared to other prices. The expert consensus: Always use a duvet cover to protect your investment. Costco’s SleepBetter Beyond Down 300TC Comforter Filled with Synthetic Down was heavy out of the bag and felt unpleasant to lie under. Lighter and loftier than others, this high-quality comforter has a silky-soft sateen shell and goose-down filling, and it feels better to sleep under than much pricier models we tried. I’ve been trying to find one over a year that wasn’t too pricey. If you're willing to splurge, this goose down comforter with a 100% Egyptian cotton cover won't disappoint. Brooklinen offers three different comforters, including one that's designed to be extra-cozy with goose down and a soft cotton shell. (Pro tip: “Duvet” is often used interchangeably with “comforter,” so don’t get confused if you hear a comforter referred to as a duvet, and vice-versa!). Fill power and feather type: 700 fill power, European white goose downConstruction: sewn-throughCertifications: Responsible Down StandardSizes available: queen, king. Oh, and also, they should be machine washable. Could you be the next one? We re-tested the Snowe Down Comforter in late 2019 after two years without testing it. Love a great deal? When winter begins to work its snowy, cold magic, you’ll want to have one of the best winter comforters at the ready. Despite its roughness, we still found the Bean’s shell breathable and woven densely enough to prevent feathers from escaping. Then we sat under each comforter for 10 to 15 minutes to get a quick sense of how they felt on our bodies. Sturdy seams are double-stitched to prevent leaks, and baffle box construction keeps the down from migrating around and making your comforter lumpy. The fill is a down alternative and it's machine washable, plus it's made with corner loops to tie on the duvet cover. Fill power is a measurement of the quality of the down, and represents how high the down will loft—essentially, how much fluff. This reviewer ditched her down comforter for this one: “This comforter is amazing! On top of that, you get to choose between four different warmth levels and four sizes to find the best fit for your bed. Not too heavy, not too light, just right.". L.L.Bean uses reinforced perma baffles, which the company says are more durable. Were they too heavy or too thin? Before making a purchase, though, give your existing comforter a wash and dry—you may see it magically return to its former fluffy glory. Keep in mind, manufacturers will often assign their own labels to their comforters, labels like medium-weight or heavyweight, that often don't check out. I used to have a down comforter but after learning about the ethical and sustainability of it, I purchased this comforter to replace. Use of this site constitutes acceptance of our User Agreement (updated 1/1/20) and Privacy Policy and Cookie Statement (updated 1/1/20) and Your California Privacy Rights. (I have you covered here.). With competing down-alternative comforters, including the pricier Brooklinen, we often woke up halfway through the night sweaty and eager to toss off the covers. We may earn commission from links on this page, but we only recommend products we back. But, enough talk. This means the Riley’s down clusters have more room to puff up inside the baffle boxes, trapping more heat, providing better insulation, and making the Riley feel perfectly warm while still being light enough to use year-round. Cuddledown’s 700 Fill Power Sateen Down Comforter felt too small and cool and Cuddledown’s 600 Fill Power Primary Down Comforter was a skimpy 88 by 92 inches.